A fine line between property development and “merely realising an asset”

There can often be a fine line between whether a person is carrying on property development activities or is “merely realising an asset”.

For example, it may not be clear whether the extent of a person’s development activity in respect of, say, subdividing his or her backyard and building one or more units of accommodation and selling them either amounts to property development or merely realizing an asset – and one that has been used mainly for domestic purposes.

And a person may be considered to be carrying on property development activities if they are not in the business of property development and it is a one-off activity.

Suffice to say, the tax consequences between property development and “merely realising an asset” are entirely different.

In the case of carrying out property development activity, the gains are assessable as ordinary income (or as business income) – and, importantly, without the benefit of the capital gains tax (CGT) 50% discount which would otherwise reduce the assessable amount.

However, relevant expenditure incurred is generally deductible as it is incurred, ie, in the income year that it is incurred. And this may be of great benefit to the developer.

On the other hand, if a person is “merely realising an asset” then any gain is only accounted for under the concessionally taxed CGT regime (and with the benefit of the 50% CGT discount, if generally the land has been owned for more than 12 months).

Furthermore, in this case, if the property in question was acquired before 20 September 1985 then there will be no consequences (either CGT or ordinary income). And there are still quite a few pre-CGT properties around that are ripe for realisation.

So, how does the Tax Office tell the difference between the two when it is not abundantly clear from the nature of the activity itself?

Well, several factors are particularly important (among the many that can be taken into account).

These include the intention with which the person originally acquired the land. To develop it and on-sell it for a profit? Or merely for some other non-profit purpose? For example, to live in it as their home (although this distinction is getting harder to tell in the current property market!).

Another key factor is the extent to which the person gets involved in the activity. As a broad principle, where a person is less involved in the activity and merely acts passively it is generally considered to be “merely realising an asset”. But this is not a hard and fast rule.

There are also import GST consequences depending on the nature of the activity and the property involved.

Finally, it should be stressed that just because the nature of the activity is a one-off transaction it does not mean that the person is immune from being taxed on the profits as ordinary or business income.

So, if you are contemplating carrying out any such activity, come and have a chat to us first so we can help you do things with the best possible tax outcomes.

< Older Post

Newer Post >

Previous Blog Posts:

Surviving (and maybe avoiding) an ATO audit

By Brad Dickfos • January 27, 2026

This article focuses on self-employed clients. If you’re a salary earner or retiree, you might find one of our other blogs more helpful.

The 50% CGT discount: More than meets the eye

By Brad Dickfos • January 9, 2026

There is much in the media about how the 50% capital gains tax (CGT) discount has contributed to the housing affordability problem in Australia (although no doubt the problem is a lot more complex than attributing it mainly to any taxation measure or measures).

Could you be missing out on thousands in lost super?

By Brad Dickfos • December 18, 2025

Most of us keep a close eye on our bank accounts. But superannuation can be easier to lose track of, especially if you’ve changed jobs, moved house, changed your name, or simply set up a new fund and assumed everything followed you. That’s why the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has issued a timely reminder. There is now $18.9 billion in lost and unclaimed super sitting across Australia. That’s up $1.1 billion since 2024 and spread across just under 7.3 million accounts. In other words, a lot of Australians have retirement savings that aren’t currently working for them and some of it could be yours. What “lost” or “unclaimed” super actually means Super doesn’t vanish, but it can go missing from your radar. It typically happens when an account becomes inactive and your super fund can’t contact you, or when you end up with multiple funds over the years. The ATO also holds certain amounts of super on behalf of individuals, for example, small inactive balances that have been transferred to the ATO, or other unclaimed amounts. The average amount of lost or unclaimed super is around $2,590 per person. That might not sound life-changing today, but over time it can grow into tens of thousands by retirement. A special note if you have an SMSF If you have an SMSF, this ATO update is particularly worth paying attention to. When you established your SMSF, you might have transferred most of your super across, but kept some behind, for example, to retain insurance cover through another fund. That means there could still be older super accounts from past jobs or retail/industry funds sitting in your name. The ATO is urging SMSF members to do a check, because a share of the $18.9 billion in lost and unclaimed super might be yours and could be rolled into your SMSF. One important practical tip is that if you locate lost super and want to move it into your SMSF, but your SMSF doesn’t show up as a transfer option in ATO online services, it’s often due to the fund’s compliance status. Take a moment to confirm your SMSF is listed as “complying” or “registered” on Super Fund Lookup. How to check for lost super (it only takes minutes) The ATO has made this super simple (pun intended!). You can: 1. Log in to myGov and go to ATO online services 2. Navigate to the Super section to view: Super held by the ATO Any lost or unclaimed accounts 3. Request a transfer to an eligible super account. Even if you don’t find anything, you’ll at least know everything is where it should be. Simple habits that help you stay on top of super Finding lost super is great but preventing it from happening at all is even better. A few easy habits can make a big difference: Keep your details up to date with your fund and the ATO so you stay contactable. Check whether you’ve got more than one account. Multiple accounts can mean multiple fees and duplicated insurance Consider consolidating if it suits your situation. Fewer accounts can mean lower fees and easier management but just be sure to check any insurance you might lose before rolling over Read your annual statement. It’s a quick way to confirm contributions, fees, returns, investment mix and beneficiaries. Why acting now matters Since 2022, the ATO has already reunited Australians with about $5.5 billion in previously unclaimed super. But there’s still nearly $19 billion waiting to be found. A few minutes today could translate into a healthier retirement balance later. It’s easy to put super in the “deal with it later” basket, but it’s still your hard-earned money. If you want a hand finding lost super, combining accounts, or moving money into your SMSF, reach out to us. We can guide you through the steps and make sure you’re able to claim any lost super without any hassles.